Let me preface this with the statement that all the artists in the following rant are people that I absolutely love and still count among my favorite musicians ever. I also want to make it clear that I do expect artists to evolve and change their style over time and albums.
As long as I like the new style.
Three artists have really (REALLY) disappointed me with their most recent offerings. (Although I have little positive to say about the albums to be mentioned, pick up anything else by these guys and you will be creamily happy with the sounds that sound in your ears). Let's talk about my bitter, bitter disappointment:
Jonah Matranga (formerly Onelinedrawing) and his album "And":
Prior to this album, Jonah could do no wrong. As his solo albums became more produced (and financed?) he threw in a few things I didn't really feel added to my album enjoyment (New York and Portland anyone?), but they were never more than a chance to take a breath before being blown
away with the next song. Will "And" is an entire album where you have time to breathe. Jonah, if you were looking to become a featured artist on Light 97, this is the direction to keep going. To make up for this poor showing, Jonah also released a couple discs of his early recordings
called "Songs from Sacramento". Please, skip "And" and pick up those instead. (The "And" Preorder Bonus disc is decent as well.. his home demos just sound better to me than the produced stuff). All this being said, Jonah is playing at the Mercury Ballroom in Manhattan in early November... I'll be there, you should as well... he is an amazing live show... just pray that he doesn't bring a slide guitar.
Badly Drawn Boy and his album "Born in the UK":
Where did my friend that created the "About a Boy Soundtrack" and "The Hour of the Bewilderbeast" go? How would I have described BDB prior to this album? Quirky and catchy Piano Based Rockpop. How do I describe this album? A rip off of 70s and 80s sad love ballads that make me cry out loud in disappointment. The worst track on the CD? "Swimming Pool" with BDB's spoken word, poetic wax of self analysis followed by a unimaginative song about how you should appreciate the little things. I don't know... this CD is just unlikable. I think I'm giving it to my mother.
Bright Eyes and his album "Cassadaga":
I actually got into Bright Eyes relatively recently and really started to appreciate his twangy folkcountry indie sound. Well with Cassadaga, turn up the twang, throw in a few extra instruments per song remove anything poppy or memorable from the songs. Maybe for the people that came to Bright Eyes from the other side of spectrum (not the post-emo indie rock side) this album is a bit more palatable. Not for me. Sorry Bright Eyes, I tried. I'll go back to "Digital Ash in a Digital Urn" and remember our good times.
So.. if you put any faith in my suggestions, skip these three albums and spend the money on their earlier albums. (Definitely buy those!) Me? Well, I'm rediscovering The Clash and starting to realize how much I really like Elbow.